Yesterday, at the Press Club in D.C., Rev. Jeremiah Wright gave a speech (transcript here) describing his church and its mission. He spoke of the ‘invisibility’ of his church’s liberation theology, about the need for an honest racial conversation, about the value of moral equality, about the need to transform injustice into justice, about global economic injustice, about his church’s many significant contributions to poverty, and about reconciliation through the acknowledgment of past grievances and forgiveness of such grievances.
During the question period a moderator read questions given to him by members of the press. They asked Wright, among other things, about his previous assertion about God damning America, whether he owes Americans an apology, Louis Farrakhan, and whether he is disappointed that Obama has distanced himself from him.
In other words, the questions and his, in my opinion level-headed responses to them, bore no relationship to the content of the speech he came there to deliver.
Today, as a way of recapping Wright’s speech and Obama’s response to it, the U.S.’s two most important editorial boards write:
NY Times: It took more time than it should have, but on Tuesday Barack Obama firmly rejected the racism and paranoia of his former pastor, the Rev. Jeremiah Wright Jr., and he made it clear that the preacher does not represent him, his politics or his campaign.
and,
WaPost: Did Mr. Obama climb out of that hole yesterday? It seems to us that the whole sorry episode raises legitimate questions about his judgment. Given the long and close relationship between Mr. Obama and the Rev. Wright, voters will ask: How could Mr. Obama have been surprised by the Rev. Wright's views?
“Racism”? I challenge the Times editorial board to point to anything in Wright’s speech that could be reasonably judged racist. How about the Washington Post’s reference to Wright’s ‘views’ as if they were bombastic and condemnatory? Which views exactly? They mean the one asserting that there is global poverty and economic injustice? Or the one about the value of moral equality? Or the one which asserts that the U.S. government has committed numerous injustices throughout its history for which it has never formally apologized?
Our mass media seems to live and report on activities from another planet, and confuses them with the happenings of our planet.
Of course, this is not true of all media outlets, as Bill Moyer’s excellent interview with Wright proves (video and transcript here).
One further unfortunate aspect of all this is to see Obama debasing himself with ridiculous political posturing. Commenting on Wright’s speech, Obama declares, “Upon watching it, what came clear to me was that it was more than just him defending himself. What became clear is that he was presenting a worldview that contradicts who I am and what I stand for. What particularly angered me was his suggestion that my previous denunciation of his remarks was political posturing.”
So, Obama stands against global economic justice, moral equality, and the church’s work to alleviate poverty? Or, if not, which ‘worldview’ is he referring to? It’s also mildly amusing that Obama is angered by Wright’s calling his political posturing, political posturing. Is he angry that he has to do it, or that someone is pointing out the obvious truth that he is engaged in it?
Wednesday, April 30, 2008
Rev. Wright's alleged sins that Obama pretends to condemn
Posted by MT Nguyen at 10:04 AM 1 comments
Labels: media, Obama, us politics
Guantanamo circus
Yesterday, the former chief prosecutor in Guantanamo took the stand--for the defense, in former Osama bin Laden driver Salim Hamdan's trial. No wallflower or bleeding heart liberal (he once compared detainees to vampires shrinking away from the bright light of American justice!), Col. Morris Davis testified that the military commissions set up to try detainees is essentially rigged and politically influenced. In addition to pointing out Bush political appointee's desire to use evidence secured through torture and the chilling demand by his superior that there can't be any acquittals, Morris asserted that "'There was that constant theme that if we don't get this thing rolling before the election, it's going to implode.' 'Once you get the victim families energized and the cases rolling, whoever took the White House would have difficulty stopping the process.'"
Evidently, the light of American justice no longer shines so bright.
Posted by MT Nguyen at 7:12 AM 0 comments
Labels: guantanamo
Tuesday, April 29, 2008
Silencing debate to achieve political good by MT Nguyen, NYC
Political dialogue is an ideal and if well-functioning seeks to discover political good. It has been repeatedly argued that this mechanism for discovering and articulating political good is the best we have. Arguably, since there is no Form (Plato™) of the political good and at any rate no agreed upon means to approach it even if it did exist, we must ground society’s pursuits on co-deliberation and subsequent collective decision. Dialogue and the freedom of speech which grounds it is the cornerstone of the value we place on our democracy.
I am not interested in debating these particular points, but rather want to explore some conditions for genuine political dialogue. In their absence, we do not have dialogue but its simulacrum. In their absence, dialogue cannot fulfill its promise to lead to political good. It is important to be able to distinguish the two because tyranny and other modes of vice often employ the mechanisms of dialogue in order to delay, divert, confuse, and obfuscate the search for and discovery of political good. In such circumstances, dialogue establishes and solidifies political power through illegitimate means. In such cases, I want to suggest, we need to silence debate’s simulacrum, stop debating, and employ principled political power to achieve political good.
A paradigmatic case of disingenuous political dialogue is the case of the holocaust deniers. They present the silencing of their argument in terms of a free speech issue. It is true that their attempts to promote their views have been in various ways thwarted, but does a free society bear a responsibility to promote any view no matter how unreasonable? For the majority of us, debate with holocaust deniers is pointless because we acknowledge the overwhelming evidence that contradicts their central tenet. Now, although it is fruitless for us to continue it, the other side insists that the majority view is the product of a massive hoax. The belief in the value of political dialogue seems to undermine our unilateral withdrawal from the discussion, and this principle suggests that it would be wrong to thwart discussion, any discussion. The first condition of political dialogue is that it should proceed as long as one side remains unconvinced and continues to say more. However, if this is the implication of our valuing political dialogue, that we must continue debating with those who hold (from one point of view) outrageously erroneous beliefs, perhaps the value is not that important after all. It seems to embroil us in an unacceptable relativism and/or skepticism about the truth of beliefs in which we are extremely confident. Must we draw these implications? Is there another way?
I believe there is, for what can happen is the recognition that one’s interlocutor is not really debating with one at all. This recognition (to be sure, a difficult point at which to arrive) releases parties from the responsibility to dialogically engage and allows them to explore other avenues, e.g. silencing opponents. This approach needn’t deny that dialogue is the correct approach to articulating political good or that there is a discoverable political good. It embraces neither relativism nor skepticism. It implies only that, given things as they are, because there is no dialogue there can be no responsibilities to further it. Applied to holocaust deniers the idea is that we can easily recognize the vicious political agenda behind their calls for a public hearing. It is this agenda, and not dialogue leading to truth, that they want to promote. And there is no political principle that compels the promotion of any political agenda no matter what.
It is true that this is treading on thin ice, for it is difficult to show that we are not silencing a political opponent merely because we do not agree with him. This makes it important to reflect upon the conditions for genuine dialogue. I’ll merely take up two vital but often ignored ones.
One essential condition of dialogue is sincerity. Even in a context in which the substance of debate is hotly contested, in which either side is unlikely to be persuaded by the other, the presumption remains that both sides believe what they assert and are engaged in the practice of justification to the other. Discussion is undermined when an interlocutor merely asserts his views and fails or refuses to acknowledge the challenges presented by his opponent; that is, there can be no dialogue when the interlocutor engages in monologue. This is, to varying extents, always the case, because when the subject matter is of great importance, the opposing sides have already to a large degree made up their minds. Nevertheless, we can demand a good faith effort to bear an open mind and to present a coherent case that can be openly discussed.
A different but connected condition of genuine political dialogue is friendship. This might seem like a strange concept to deploy in our agonistic democracy where political contestants seem to disdain one another, but it is not. The idea of political dialogue as an essential component of political good requires friendship at least in the sense that the project of discovering political good is a shared one grounded in a mutual respect for its participants. Obviously, the concept of friendship here does not refer to mutual personal emotional attachment, but rather civic friendship. This is not compatible with mutual disdain, but is compatible with, as typical friendships are, heated argument and permanent disagreement.
We in the U.S. are now in the midst of a simulated public discourse over whether certain undisclosed (really, open-ended) interrogation techniques (read: torture) are morally permissible and legitimate or whether they are morally impermissible and/or violate international law. This so-called dialogue continues and promises to continue until some indefinite time in the future. For those of us who believe that there can be no debate regarding torture, it is frustrating (to say the least) to observe this continuing back and forth between congress and members of the Bush administration. We believe the back and forth must end, for while it occurs people are having their dignity stripped, are being degraded, tortured and killed. Dialogue, just like other activities, can have dire consequences.
As I have been arguing, however, we do not need to end discussion on the grounds that we do not believe what the other side says or that it leads to bad consequences. We can end it by suggesting that the other side is toying with us, holds us in contempt, and is insincere in its pronouncements. There is no space here to demonstrate that the Bush administration’s actions evidence a failure of each of the conditions for genuine discussion. For anyone following their moves, however, the case is not difficult to make: the legal acrobatics in a ‘torture memo’ written by a tenured law professor who, by all accounts, otherwise possesses a sound legal mind; the paranoid secrecy and duplicity which discloses information and relevant documents only upon being compelled; the ever changing, unprincipled, and obfuscating interpretations of the concept of torture; and, lastly, the contemptible and surely insincere attempt to distinguish Spanish Inquisition waterboarding from U.S. waterboarding. Each new month brings us a fresh perspective on the Bush administration’s tactics and none of them evidence any attempt to justify to others and do anything but push forward through brute force and occasional gerrymandering an egregious political agenda.
Knowing all this we need to adjust our response and make them appropriate to the conditions at hand. M.L. King recognized this more than 40 years ago when he abandoned dialogue with white supremacists who promised much but delivered nothing, and began employing civil disobedience. The call to confront an egregious agenda does not mean, obviously, that anything goes or that politics is reduced to brute exertions of power. The language and value of persuasion, dialogue, and debate are with us and our democracy, and this is verified by their use even by those who do not believe in their value. We can confront (non-dialogically) insincere and disdainful political opponents by compelling them with whatever legitimate powers we have to live by words and concepts they themselves use. We can do this not with the purpose of crushing them, but to bring them back into the fold, motivating them to engage us on terms grounded in civic friendship. If we are to articulate through political dialogue our conception of political good, sometimes principled political force used in the service of dialogue is the only way to do it.
Posted by MT Nguyen at 10:34 AM 1 comments
Labels: an essay, an intervention, us politics
Friday, April 25, 2008
Propaganda
It's not terribly surprising, but the New York Times's recent blockbuster demonstrates connections between allegedly objective military analysts/talking heads who work for the various networks and the Bush administration.
"Internal Pentagon documents repeatedly refer to the military analysts as 'message force multipliers' or 'surrogates' who could be counted on to deliver administration 'themes and messages' to millions of Americans 'in the form of their own opinions.'"
In the nature of things, there were repeated denials of wrongdoing. Read the article to make up your own mind.
Posted by MT Nguyen at 9:15 AM 0 comments
Labels: media
Holding accountable for human rights abuses
Roger Alford at OpinioJuris has a very instructive post (and link to his article) on an emerging legal strategy for holding nations accountable for human rights abuses. There are various legal barriers/difficulties to directly sanctioning nations, so some have taken to suing corporations which work with rights abusing nations instead. The upshot and hope of this strategy is that the corporations will in turn incorporate rights preserving/protecting measures in their contracts with sovereign nations. If sued, corporations will have legal avenues to pursue nations to have them help pay for damages. The upshot is that nations will then have a monetary incentive for avoiding rights abuses.
I'm not crazy about the idea of a market for human rights violations (Alford does not advocate this, but merely describes it), but if it helps facilitate a downturn in their incidence, then so much the better.
His accompanying law review article is well worth reading.
Posted by MT Nguyen at 8:45 AM 0 comments
Labels: corporations, human rights, law
Thursday, April 24, 2008
The Record-Breaking President
With the presidential election looming, one is naturally driven to evaluate the recent past. Like many, I had a hunch that Bush will be seen as one of the worst presidents in US history. But I no longer have it; now it’s confirmed. Bush has earned the podium in the history of the Gallup Poll. He has broken records such as “the most disapproved president,” “the president disapproved for the longest time,” and a few others. It seems that at the very least Bush has broken the record of breaking the most negative records in the history of the Gallup Poll.
Posted by Matias Bulnes at 1:31 PM 0 comments
Wednesday, April 23, 2008
The End of an Era
Fernando Lugo has won the presidency in Paraguay. Lugo leads an alliance between leftists and liberals, forged to defeat the Colorado Party which had been in power for longer than he had been alive. This defeat tops a long transition to democracy in South America. Unlike Argentina, Brazil and Chile, Paraguay’s dictatorship had been intimately associated with the Colorado Party which remained in power long after Stroessner, head of the party and army, left office in 1989. The Colorado Party had dominated Paraguayan politics based on a heavy, overarching political structure, in spite of permanent suspicions of corruption and electoral fraud.
An important question is what changed in South America that allowed for democracy? A full answer will probably require many considerations. But there is at least one important historical event that obviously plays a tremendous role in the explanation: the end of the Cold War. All dictatorships in South America during the 60s and 70s were US-supported (although the Paraguayan one begun in the 50s). After the Cuban experience in the late 50s, and the subsequent Chilean experience during the late 60s, the US began to see South America as a limb infected by the Communist plague and decided to apply shock therapy.
This is not to say that the US was the cause of the extreme political polarization that marked South American politics at the time. This polarization was inherent to these countries and exacerbated by the Cold War itself. In fact, it seems reasonable to regard it as the main cause of the political disaster of the 70s and 80s in South America. Hadn’t the US supported those dictatorships, probably the USSR would have funded inverse but equally cruel regimes.
Be as it may, with the Cold War in the past and much less attention from the super powers, South America has got that long needed breath to reorganize its politics and strive. Moreover the course seems to be set toward a more progressive form of society. Paraguay joins Chile, Venezuela, Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay, Bolivia, and Ecuador in having democratically elected socialist/liberal governments. Congratulations to Paraguay.
Posted by Matias Bulnes at 4:23 AM 0 comments
Thursday, April 17, 2008
The banalization of torture
This Washington Post article must be read to see one comi-tragic implication of our waterboarding policy. The plaintiff and defendant claim not to have known what waterboarding is. I'm highly skeptical of that, especially in the case of the defendant.
The ultimate quote: “And it's widely acknowledged that the supervisor, Joshua Christopherson, then told the assembled sales team, whose numbers had been lagging: ‘You saw how hard Chad fought for air right there. I want you to go back inside and fight that hard to make sales.’”
I’ll leave it at that, so you can go read the article.
Posted by MT Nguyen at 11:35 AM 0 comments
Labels: torture
Wednesday, April 16, 2008
Socratic method
Socrates’ method, sometimes called the Elenchus, aims to reveal the cognitive health of his interlocutors. After answering a range of questions, typically concerning ethical concepts, the interlocutor is supposed to come to the conclusion either that his beliefs are consistent with one another, meaning that he is cognitively healthy, or that they are not, meaning that there is some cognitive dissonance and disease.
Let’s try this out on Americans, particularly those who were recently polled.
A recent AP/Ipsos poll registers Bush at a 70% disapproval rating for his handling of the economy.
Yesterday, just in time for paying one’s taxes, McCain outlined his economic policy in a speech (text here) at Carnegie Mellon. He advocates making permanent Bush’s tax cuts, as well as a whole host of other tax cuts, free (really?) trade, and ‘reforming and protecting’ of Medicare and Social Security (I’m scared to know what ‘reform and protect’ means; perhaps something like ‘to destroy in order to make better’). In other words, as many have pointed out, he is more or less like Bush with respect to handling the economy.
Putting those two together, the consistent position would be that McCain’s numbers on the economy should be fairly low.
However, yesterday Reuters/Zogby released its poll. The relevant question was whether McCain, Clinton or Obama would be a better steward of the economy. The results: McCain led, 3pts over Obama and 5 over Clinton.
At this point, Socrates would expect his interlocutor, recognizing the disease of his mind, to alter one of his beliefs, given that they are in tension with one another. Can we expect Americans, who are evidently blinded by McCain’s reputation as a straight shooter, to be as rational?
Posted by MT Nguyen at 12:22 PM 0 comments
Labels: McCain, us politics
Tuesday, April 15, 2008
If "terrorists" doesn't work out, we've got a backup official enemy
The following comes by way of our friend, Josephus P. Franks, who writes at Brand R denotes Respectability.
See also On Hypocrisy Over Tibet by John V. Whitbeck
I love listening to the U.S. government denounce the Chinese government for the latter's lack of respect for human rights - it's like watching a serial rapist berate Larry Flynt for degrading women. It's cheap irony, but good fun. I can't understand why anyone wouldn't enjoy this - after all, wouldn't it be a blast to watch a press conference where some grand dragon wizard from the Klu Klux Klan denounces Univision for disproportionately showing light-skinned Latin Americans in their broadcasts?
It's hard to pick a favorite aspect of this situation - is it that the U.S. government practices torture as an instrument of policy while its representatives criticize China's human rights standards? Or is it that Western media sources used images of Tibetan protests in Nepal - whose monarchical government, before it was overthrown by the Maoists, enjoyed friendly relations with the U.S. government - and pawned them off as pictures of Chinese police cracking down on peaceful protesters?
[The Washington Post expresses its regret that its graphic artists are on strike. The editorial board has taken on all Photoshop responsibilities.]
Posted by MT Nguyen at 1:50 PM 0 comments
